Review · THE UK
Edinburgh: The Lost Close Underground Scotch Whisky Tasting
The unusual part comes first: you leave the Royal Mile and head underground into The Lost Close, a newly uncovered vault beneath Edinburgh’s Old Town. Four Scotch whiskies, four distilleries, and stories about the people and schemes that shaped the whisky trade make this more than a quick drink at a bar.
I like the regional comparison, which gives beginners a useful way to notice how Scotch can differ from one part of Scotland to another. I also like the guides’ relaxed style. Eleanor, Mark, Rosie, Sarah, Nikki, and others are praised for mixing facts with jokes and adjusting pours to personal tastes. The main consideration is that the basic tasting may feel brief for serious whisky fans, and the intermediate or high-end options cost more.
Key points at a glance

- Four whiskies from four distilleries: Taste examples linked to Scotland’s main whisky-producing regions.
- An underground Old Town setting: Enter The Lost Close from a meeting point just off the Royal Mile, behind St Giles Cathedral.
- Stories with every pour: Guides explain whisky-making history and introduce some of the characters behind the industry.
- Three tasting levels: Choose the standard flight, upgrade to four rarer drams, or select five high-end whiskies.
- A friendly small-group feel: Groups may be split into smaller sections, making questions and conversation easier.
- A compact evening plan: The advertised duration is 1.5 hours, though some sessions run closer to 60 to 75 minutes.
Entering The Lost Close beneath Edinburgh’s Old Town

You meet outside John’s Coffee House & Tavern, just off the Royal Mile on Parliament Square, behind St Giles Cathedral. This detail matters because the venue itself is not an obvious street-level whisky bar. You need to arrive at the stated meeting point, where your guide leads the group below the Old Town.
The Lost Close is an underground area recently uncovered for use as a tasting venue. Its stone, enclosed setting gives the evening a clear sense of place. I would not book this only for the room, since the whisky and guide carry the experience, but the underground surroundings make the tasting feel tied to Edinburgh rather than copied from a hotel bar.
The setting is cozy and intimate. One useful feature is the possibility of smaller groups, with larger gatherings sometimes divided into two sections. That gives you more room to ask about a particular bottle, compare notes, or admit that one whisky tastes like a campfire while another seems softer and fruitier.
You should expect stairs or uneven access associated with an underground venue. The experience is not suitable for wheelchair users, babies under one year, children under 18, or pregnant women. Smoking is not allowed indoors.
Food and drink tours around Edinburgh:
- Edinburgh: Gin Tasting at Underground Venue
★ 4.9 · 84 reviews - Early morning Chichen Itza Tour: Cenote and Tequila Tasting
★ 5.0 · 6,657 reviews - Cancun ATV Jungle Adventure, Ziplines, Cenote and Tequila Tasting
★ 4.5 · 4,873 reviews
How the four-whisky tasting works

The standard experience gives you four whiskies from four distilleries, representing Scotland’s major whisky-producing regions. The point is not simply to drink four glasses. Your guide uses the pours to show how place, production, and style can affect what you smell and taste.
For a first tasting, this structure works well. Instead of meeting one bottle in isolation, you can compare one dram with the next. You may notice differences in smoke, sweetness, weight, spice, or finish. You do not need a trained palate, and the guides make room for simple reactions. If you like one whisky and dislike another, that is useful information.
The regional approach also helps if you plan to buy a bottle later. Several guides, including Mark, have offered suggestions for bottles to take home. The tasting can save you from choosing a label based only on its packaging or reputation. Pay attention to the style you prefer, then ask for a recommendation within that style.
Your guide also explains how the Scotch industry began and grew. The storytelling includes unusual people and entertaining episodes, rather than stopping at dry production facts. Pip described the historical material as a strong part of the experience, and that balance is important. A whisky tasting can become dull if every pour turns into a lecture. Here, the history gives the glasses a reason to be there.
What the guides add to the evening

The guide is the key variable in any tasting, and this experience has drawn repeated praise for its hosts. Eleanor is described as relaxed, witty, and able to keep a very small group engaged. Mark is noted for clear explanations, humor, and useful bottle advice. Rosie brings humor and a strong grasp of the historical side, while Sarah has been especially good at making groups feel welcome.
Other guides named during the sessions include Nikki, Nicky, Hayley, Haley, Lydia, James, and Dan. Names aside, the consistent pattern is clear: you can expect the host to do more than pour whisky and read a label. The best sessions respond to the group in front of them.
That flexibility matters if your party has mixed interests. One person may arrive as the whisky enthusiast, while another is trying Scotch for the first time. Eleanor helped one couple in which the husband already loved whisky, while his partner developed a new interest during the tasting. A good host can give the expert something to think about without leaving the beginner behind.
The guides also seem willing to listen to preferences. One couple disliked peaty, smoky whisky, and the guide provided a non-peated Islay choice so they could still experience the region. That is a thoughtful touch, but you should still expect whisky to be the focus. If you dislike strong spirits altogether, this may not be the right activity.
Choosing the standard, intermediate, or high-end flight

The $53 standard price is fair if you want a guided introduction in a memorable location. You are paying for four drams, the host’s explanations, access to the underground venue, and a compact history lesson. It is not the cheapest way to sample Scotch, but buying four comparable pours independently, then adding a guide and a historic room, would not necessarily offer better value.
The standard flight suits most first-time tasters. It gives you enough range to identify broad preferences without making the evening too heavy. If your main goal is to understand the difference between regions and learn basic tasting habits, I would start here.
The intermediate option includes four rarer, older, or more unusual whiskies. Some may be bottles you would not normally find in a whisky shop, while others may be older versions of familiar labels. This is the strongest upgrade for someone who already knows a little about Scotch and wants to compare less common expressions.
The high-end option includes five top-shelf whiskies. These are the bottles you might admire in a shop but hesitate to buy for yourself. Choose this level for a special occasion, a whisky-focused birthday, or a group with a serious interest in premium spirits. Nadine’s family used the luxury flight for a 70th birthday, and the format suited a milestone celebration.
Do not assume the expensive option is automatically the best choice. A beginner may find stronger or older whiskies less approachable. One person who chose the intermediate package found the whisky quite powerful despite enjoying the tour. If you are new to Scotch, the standard flight lets you learn what you like before spending more on rare pours.
Same rock, a different way in:
- Edinburgh: Underground Vaults Tour
★ 4.6 · 11,758 reviews - The World Famous Underground Ghost Tour
★ 4.5 · 9,272 reviews - Underground Vaults Walking Tour in Edinburgh Old Town
★ 4.5 · 8,506 reviews - Edinburgh: Haunted Underground Vaults and Graveyard Tour
★ 4.6 · 6,607 reviews
A practical 90 minutes of whisky and stories

The advertised duration is 1.5 hours, and that fits well before dinner or after a day of sightseeing. Some sessions have lasted closer to 60 to 75 minutes, so do not build a complicated schedule around every available minute. You should have enough time for the four standard pours and the explanations, but this is not a long, leisurely meal.
You begin at the Old Town meeting point, follow the guide underground, and settle into the tasting room. The guide introduces the basic idea of tasting, then works through the whisky selection while explaining regional differences and the wider story of Scotch.
Expect the pace to depend on group size and questions. A quiet small group may move quickly. A lively group may spend longer discussing a favorite pour. Guests have met people from several countries during the sessions, which can make the evening feel social without turning it into a loud pub crawl.
There is no food included, and transportation is not included. Plan to eat before or after, especially if you are not used to tasting spirits. The venue is central, so it fits neatly into an Old Town itinerary, but the meeting point is the place to focus on, not a separate distillery outside Edinburgh.
The legal drinking age in Scotland is 18. This is an adult activity, and everyone in your booking needs to meet that requirement.
The value of the underground venue

Edinburgh has plenty of places to drink whisky, so the setting needs to offer more than a dark room and a few bottles. The Lost Close does that by placing the tasting below the city streets, in a space connected to the old fabric of Edinburgh.
You should keep your expectations sensible. This is not described as a full archaeological tour, and the focus remains whisky. You are not spending 90 minutes exploring every corner of an underground complex. Instead, the room creates atmosphere while the guide supplies the context.
That combination works best at the start or end of a day in the Old Town. After walking the Royal Mile and seeing St Giles Cathedral, you can step into a very different Edinburgh below ground. The change in setting makes the tasting feel like an activity, not just a purchase of drinks.
The room also helps a birthday or anniversary feel special without requiring a formal dinner. One host even sang Happy Birthday to a participant, showing how personal the tone can become when the group is small and the guide is willing to play along.
What kind of whisky drinker will enjoy this?

I would recommend the standard experience to a curious beginner who wants a clear introduction without committing to a full whisky course. You get a useful regional framework, four samples, and plenty of help from the guide.
It also suits a mixed couple or family group, provided everyone is 18 or older. The whisky fan can ask detailed questions, while the newcomer can focus on taste and learn at a comfortable pace. The guides have shown they can adjust the conversation and, where possible, account for preferences such as low smoke.
The intermediate package fits someone who already recognizes a few Scotch labels and wants unusual or older versions. The high-end package is best for a whisky collector, a milestone birthday, or someone who values the chance to taste bottles they would not buy outright.
I would be more cautious if you have limited mobility, are pregnant, or want a food-pairing event. None of those needs matches the structure here. I would also skip it if you dislike spirits or want a long technical lesson on distilling. The storytelling is engaging, but the experience is designed as a tasting with history, not a specialist training course.
Timing, meeting point, and booking advice

Allow enough time to find John’s Coffee House & Tavern. The meeting point is outside the tavern, behind St Giles Cathedral on Parliament Square, just off the Royal Mile. The group heads underground from there.
English is the tour language, and the activity uses a live guide. Small groups may be available, which is worth selecting if you prefer a quieter session and more direct conversation.
You can cancel up to 24 hours before the activity for a full refund, and reserve now while paying later. Those terms are useful in Edinburgh, where weather, festivals, and changing sightseeing plans can affect an evening.
Wear something comfortable for an underground setting, and avoid arriving on an empty stomach. Food is not included, and the tasting contains several whiskies in a fairly short period. If you plan to upgrade, decide based on your interest, not just the promise of a higher price tag.
Should you book The Lost Close tasting?

Book it if you want a guided first taste of Scotch, a historic underground room, and a host who can make whisky history easy to follow. The four-region format offers a useful starting point, and the standard price gives you enough variety to decide what you like.
Choose the intermediate or high-end flight if whisky is already a serious interest or you are marking a special occasion. Beginners should not feel pressured to upgrade. The basic tasting is the better value for learning, while the premium options are about access to rarer bottles.
Skip it if you need step-free access, food with your drinks, or a long distillery visit. For most adults spending time in Edinburgh’s Old Town, though, this is a compact and personable way to meet Scotch whisky underground, with more substance than a casual dram at the bar.
FAQ
Where does the Scotch whisky tasting meet?
Meet outside John’s Coffee House & Tavern on Parliament Square, just off the Royal Mile and behind St Giles Cathedral. The group goes underground from there.
How long does the experience last?
The advertised duration is 1.5 hours. Some sessions may run closer to 60 to 75 minutes.
How many whiskies are included in the standard tasting?
The standard tasting includes four whiskies from four different distilleries, representing Scotland’s major whisky-producing regions.
What does the intermediate upgrade include?
The intermediate option includes four rarer, older, or more unusual whisky drams. These may include bottles not commonly found in whisky shops or older versions of familiar whiskies.
What does the high-end option include?
The high-end option includes five top-shelf whisky drams.
Is food included?
No. Food is not included in the tasting.
Is transportation included?
No. Transportation is not included. You make your own way to the meeting point on Parliament Square.
Is the tour offered in English?
Yes. The activity has a live English-speaking guide.
Who cannot take part?
The experience is not suitable for children under 18, babies under one year, wheelchair users, or pregnant women. Scotland’s legal drinking age is 18.
Can I cancel my booking?
Yes. You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund. You can also reserve now and pay later, keeping your plans flexible.
Newly added caves around Edinburgh
- Edinburgh: Underground Vaults and Graveyard Evening Tour★ 4.4 · 393 reviews
- Edinburgh: Gin Tasting at Underground Venue★ 4.9 · 84 reviews
- Edinburgh: Kids Multi-Sensory Underground Small-Group Tour★ 4.7 · 52 reviews
- Edinburgh: Extreme Paranormal Underground Ghost Tour★ 4.2 · 850 reviews
- Edinburgh: Late-Night Underground Vaults Terror Tour★ 4.6 · 4,162 reviews
- Edinburgh: Witches & Haunted History Walking Tour★ 4.8 · 1,290 reviews
- Extreme Paranormal Underground Ghost Tour in Edinburgh★ 4.5 · 1,587 reviews
- Multi-Sensory Haunted Underground Vaults Tour in Edinburgh★ 4.5 · 1,649 reviews
UK Cave Tours worth comparing.

Underground Vaults Walking Tour in Edinburgh Old Town
Read our review →
Edinburgh: Haunted Underground Vaults and Graveyard Tour
Read our review →
Edinburgh: Late-Night Underground Vaults Terror Tour
Read our review →
Edinburgh: Multi-Sensory Haunted Underground Tour
Read our review →
Edinburgh: Underground Vaults Evening Ghost Tour with Whisky
Read our review →Lists this cave tour appears in



