Review · THE UK

Edinburgh: Gin Tasting at Underground Venue

★ 4.9 · 84 reviews 1 hour From $36 Operated by 1A PSQ Ltd · Bookable on GetYourGuide
Book on GetYourGuide →

Edinburgh’s gin story unfolds underground, inside The Lost Close, an atmospheric old venue just behind St Giles Cathedral. You taste four very different gins while your guide explains how the drink moved from Jenever to Old Tom, Navy Strength, and London Dry. Some sessions have even taken place in an old jail cell, which gives the hour a theatrical edge.

I like the mix of real history and hands-on tasting, and I like that you choose your own tonic and garnish instead of being handed four fixed drinks. The main drawback is time: one hour passes quickly, so this suits a focused introduction rather than a long, leisurely gin class. It is also strictly for adults and not suitable during pregnancy.

  • Underground setting: Enter The Lost Close from Parliament Square, behind St Giles Cathedral.
  • Four distinct gins: Compare different styles and flavours rather than tasting the same spirit four times.
  • Make your own serve: Match each gin with a tonic and garnish to suit your taste.
  • Gin through the centuries: Follow the spirit from Jenever to Old Tom, Navy Strength, and London Dry.
  • Strong storytelling: Guides including Sarah, Sara, Nicky, and Dan bring history, humour, and local character.
  • Compact format: The one-hour session fits neatly before dinner or an evening walk through Edinburgh.

Entering The Lost Close from Parliament Square

Edinburgh: Gin Tasting at Underground Venue - Entering The Lost Close from Parliament Square

The meeting point is outside John’s Coffee House & Tavern, just off the Royal Mile and behind St Giles Cathedral on Parliament Square. That location matters: you are already in the oldest-feeling part of central Edinburgh, and the experience moves you below the street rather than into another standard bar.

You do not need to arrange transport. Make your way to the meeting point on foot and look for the guide outside the tavern. From there, the group heads underground into The Lost Close.

The setting is a major part of the experience. The venue has the enclosed, slightly mysterious feel you want from an underground Edinburgh activity. One attendee described sitting in an old jail cell while sipping gin, a wonderfully odd combination that makes this more than a tasting counter with a few bottles lined up.

The space also helps the group settle in together. Sessions can include small groups, with one group of six described as especially comfortable. Exact group size is not given for every departure, so you should not book expecting a private tasting, but the format is built around conversation and a shared presentation.

A one-hour route through gin’s changing styles

Edinburgh: Gin Tasting at Underground Venue - A one-hour route through gin’s changing styles

The session follows the evolution of gin, not simply a list of samples. Your guide begins with the spirit’s early origins and traces its development through several named styles.

You will hear about Jenever, the older spirit that helped shape gin’s early identity. The story then moves through Old Tom, Navy Strength, and London Dry. These names can sound like specialist bar language, but the tasting gives them a practical purpose. You can connect each stage of the talk with what is in your glass.

That is the best reason to choose this activity over a basic gin flight. You are not just being told that the samples are different. You are given a framework for noticing how production and style affect flavour.

The Scottish connection is also part of the talk. The activity presents gin within Scotland’s wider story, rather than treating it as a drink with no sense of place. The venue’s own history adds a second layer, so you are listening to stories about both the spirit and the room around you.

Guides Sarah and Sara receive especially strong praise for making the history easy to follow, with humour and amusing details. Nicky and Dan are also named as warm, professional hosts. The style can vary by guide, but the consistent aim is clear: this is a storytelling session with drinks, not a technical lecture.

Four gins, four chances to find your style

Edinburgh: Gin Tasting at Underground Venue - Four gins, four chances to find your style

The tasting includes four different gins. The exact brands are not specified, so I would not book this expecting particular labels or a fixed menu. What you can count on is contrast, with the samples selected to show how broad gin can be.

Your guide explains flavour profiles and suggests suitable mixers. You then add tonic and garnish yourself. That small choice makes the tasting more useful because you learn something about your own preferences instead of simply accepting the bartender’s recipe.

You might find that you prefer a bold, spirit-forward drink, or you might discover that a lighter tonic combination works better for you. The point is not to prove there is one correct gin and tonic. It is to compare, adjust, and notice what changes when the mixer and garnish change.

The tonics and garnishes are included. Since they are part of the tasting, you can compare different pairings as you go. This also keeps the session social: people can discuss how they mixed their drinks and see how the same gin changes from one glass to another.

The four samples are not presented as four large cocktails. This is a tasting, so you should expect measured portions rather than a full evening of drinking. That makes the experience manageable within an hour, but you should still plan around alcohol. It is not suitable for children under 18, babies under one year, or pregnant women.

Why the tonic story is worth hearing

Edinburgh: Gin Tasting at Underground Venue - Why the tonic story is worth hearing

Tonic water has its own place in the presentation. The talk explains how tonic was first used for medicinal purposes and how it became gin’s natural partner.

That detail helps explain a familiar drink without making the subject feel overcomplicated. You learn why tonic is not simply a sweet soft drink added at the end. Its bitterness and freshness can change the balance of a gin, and the choice of tonic matters as much as the choice of spirit.

This is where the activity works well for someone who likes gin but has never learned how to taste it. Your guide gives you a few useful ideas: compare the aroma, notice the main flavour, try the suggested tonic, then adjust the drink with your own garnish.

You do not need prior knowledge. The talk is in English, and the guides keep the tone lively rather than formal. Several sessions are described as amusing and theatrical, which is useful if you want a night out with some learning but do not want a classroom.

The guide makes or breaks the hour

Edinburgh: Gin Tasting at Underground Venue - The guide makes or breaks the hour

A short tasting depends heavily on the person leading it. Here, the guide is not just pouring drinks. The host carries the history, explains the production styles, answers questions, and keeps the group moving.

Sarah is repeatedly singled out in the feedback, with her storytelling, jokes, and warm manner making a strong impression. Sara is also described as enthusiastic and entertaining. Nicky and Dan are praised for being welcoming, friendly, and well prepared.

Names can change from one departure to another, so do not assume Sarah will lead your session. Still, the pattern of praise suggests that the provider puts real weight on presentation. One guide stayed beyond the planned time to answer questions, though you should not treat extra time as guaranteed.

You can ask questions during the session, especially if one style interests you more than another. If you are already a gin fan, this is a chance to ask about production and tonic pairings. If you are new to gin, ask the guide to explain why the samples taste so different.

Same rock, a different way in:

What makes the underground venue special

Edinburgh: Gin Tasting at Underground Venue - What makes the underground venue special

The Lost Close supplies atmosphere that a normal tasting room cannot match. You are below Edinburgh’s busy central streets, in a place with a strong sense of age and enclosure.

The setting is not a full museum visit, and this is not presented as a long architectural tour. The venue is there to support the gin story and give the tasting a memorable backdrop. That distinction matters. If you want detailed information about every part of the building, this may feel brief. If you want a drink with a strange and atmospheric setting, it works very well.

The old jail-cell setting described by one attendee gives you a clear idea of the mood. It is quirky rather than polished. Expect character, not a glossy modern distillery showroom.

The atmosphere also makes this a good first activity for an evening in Edinburgh. You are near the Royal Mile, close to restaurants and historic sights, and the one-hour format leaves room for dinner afterward. One attendee specifically used it as a way to begin an Edinburgh evening.

Is $36 good value for one hour?

Edinburgh: Gin Tasting at Underground Venue - Is $36 good value for one hour?

At $36 per person, the price is fair if you value the setting and the guided presentation, not just the alcohol. You receive four gins, tonics, garnishes, an expert-led talk, and access to The Lost Close.

A standard bar flight might cost less, but it would not normally include a structured account of gin’s development, tonic’s origins, Scotland’s connection to the spirit, and an underground venue. On the other hand, someone seeking a long distillery tour or a large number of generous pours may find the one-hour format limited.

The value is strongest for couples, friends, and curious drinkers who want an activity with a story. It is less compelling if you already know the major gin styles and only want to sample particular brands, since the exact gins are not listed.

The tasting also gives you practical value beyond the hour. You leave with a better sense of which tonic and garnish combinations suit you. That can help you order more confidently later, rather than choosing a gin and tonic at random.

Timing, reservations, and practical details

Edinburgh: Gin Tasting at Underground Venue - Timing, reservations, and practical details

The duration is one hour, with starting times available according to the date you choose. I would allow a little extra time to reach the meeting point, since the entrance is near the Royal Mile but the actual activity begins outside John’s Coffee House & Tavern.

The activity is conducted in English with a live guide. Transportation is not included, but none is required as part of the experience. You meet in central Edinburgh and head underground from there.

Smoking is not allowed indoors. The activity is for adults aged 18 and over, and it is not suitable for pregnant women or babies under one year.

You can cancel up to 24 hours before the start for a full refund. The reserve-now, pay-later option can also help if your Edinburgh plans are still shifting. These policies are useful for a short city break, when weather, dinner bookings, and sightseeing plans can change.

Who should book this Edinburgh gin tasting?

Edinburgh: Gin Tasting at Underground Venue - Who should book this Edinburgh gin tasting?

I would choose this for:

  • Couples looking for a compact evening activity
  • Friends who enjoy trying different drinks together
  • Gin drinkers who want to understand styles and mixers
  • Visitors who like unusual historic settings
  • People who prefer storytelling to a purely technical tasting
  • Anyone wanting an activity near the Royal Mile before dinner

It is also a good choice for someone who does not normally order gin but wants an easy introduction. The four samples give you room to compare, while the tonic choices help soften the experience if you prefer a lighter drink.

I would skip it if you need a non-alcoholic activity, want a private group, or are looking for detailed production demonstrations. The venue and storytelling are central here, while the exact brands and distilling process are not specified.

Should you book The Lost Close tasting?

Edinburgh: Gin Tasting at Underground Venue - Should you book The Lost Close tasting?

Book it if you want an atmospheric hour, four contrasting gins, and a guide-led story that connects the drink with Scottish history. The old underground setting gives the activity a character that a standard bar tasting lacks, and the chance to choose your own tonic and garnish makes the session practical as well as entertaining.

The main caution is the short length and unspecified gin selection. You are buying a polished introduction, not a full distillery visit or an all-night drinking session.

For most adults spending time around the Royal Mile, I think the combination of setting, storytelling, and tasting makes $36 reasonable. It is especially easy to fit before dinner, and the strongest guides, including Sarah, Sara, Nicky, and Dan, make the hour feel lively rather than stiff.

FAQ

Where does the gin tasting meet?

Meet outside John’s Coffee House & Tavern, just off the Royal Mile behind St Giles Cathedral on Parliament Square. The group heads underground from there to The Lost Close.

How long does the activity last?

The tasting lasts one hour. Starting times depend on availability for the date you select.

How many gins are included?

You taste four different gins during the session.

Are tonic water and garnishes included?

Yes. Tonics and garnishes are included, and you can mix the drinks to suit your taste.

What does the guide explain?

The guide covers the origins and development of gin, its connection to Scotland, the styles Jenever, Old Tom, Navy Strength, and London Dry, and the history of tonic water.

Is the activity conducted in English?

Yes. The live tour guide speaks English.

Is transportation included?

No. Transportation is not included. You make your own way to the central meeting point outside John’s Coffee House & Tavern.

Can I cancel the booking?

Yes. You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund. A reserve-now, pay-later option is also available.

More like this

UK Cave Tours worth comparing.

The full list: UK Cave Tours →
Edinburgh: Underground Vaults Tour
★★★★★★★★★★4.6· 11,758 reviews· from $32

Edinburgh: Underground Vaults Tour

Read our review →
The World Famous Underground Ghost Tour
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 9,272 reviews· from $26

The World Famous Underground Ghost Tour

Read our review →
Underground Vaults Walking Tour in Edinburgh Old Town
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 8,506 reviews· from $33

Underground Vaults Walking Tour in Edinburgh Old Town

Read our review →
Edinburgh: Haunted Underground Vaults and Graveyard Tour
★★★★★★★★★★4.6· 6,607 reviews· from $32

Edinburgh: Haunted Underground Vaults and Graveyard Tour

Read our review →
Edinburgh: Late-Night Underground Vaults Terror Tour
★★★★★★★★★★4.6· 4,162 reviews· from $35

Edinburgh: Late-Night Underground Vaults Terror Tour

Read our review →
Edinburgh: Evening Underground Ghost Tour
★★★★★★★★★★4.4· 3,092 reviews· from $26

Edinburgh: Evening Underground Ghost Tour

Read our review →
Edinburgh: Multi-Sensory Haunted Underground Tour
★★★★★★★★★★4.5· 2,721 reviews· from $29

Edinburgh: Multi-Sensory Haunted Underground Tour

Read our review →
Edinburgh: Underground Vaults Evening Ghost Tour with Whisky
★★★★★★★★★★4.7· 2,685 reviews· from $33

Edinburgh: Underground Vaults Evening Ghost Tour with Whisky

Read our review →

Lists this cave tour appears in

Scroll to Top

Go underground

Choose the way in: by boat, by paddle, on foot or on the ice.